But even on Walsh’s point, he wasn’t right. This argument is the same as when someone says that the Bible is true because it’s the “best-selling” book of all time. Okay, so the view that every single person on Earth has held up until 15 seconds ago is extreme, and the view that almost everyone does right now still still hold is extreme, apparently, according to her.Īn extreme, offensive belief held by many people can still be extreme and offensive. She began by saying that my view is extreme. Suzy D’Enbeau, a gender and communication expert from Kent State University, called Walsh’s views extreme, he countered, It has been doing that long before it was verbal. Language is not some ancient objective truth. Walsh also acted like language was on his side here. Others calling you by your chosen name is a form of respect.
#FULL DR PHIL EPISODES ONLINE HOW TO#
Pronouns are a substitute for your name, and you have a right to tell people how to refer to you. He might not be mortally offended if you refuse to call him handsome and brilliant, but he’d almost certainly flip out if I resolved to only use she/her pronouns for him. You don’t get your own adjectives - which is what Walsh offered - but you do get your own pronouns. It’s like if I were to tell you my adjectives are handsome and brilliant, and no matter what, whenever you’re talking about me you have to describe me as handsome and brilliant because that’s how I identify, makes no sense. You don’t get your own pronouns, just like you don’t get your own prepositions or your own adjectives.
Just to clarify, with all due respect, most of what we just heard in the previous segment was total nonsense, which is why when you were pushing for definitions and that sort of thing that they were not able to provide it, because it’s just nonsensical.Īfter his predictable tirade on why he believes the word “woman” can only be defined as “adult human female,” the right-wing talking points kept pouring out and hit their peak when he used an analogy to refute the entire concept of using personal pronouns:
0 kommentar(er)
